What’s Better in Puzzles and Games – Loud or Quiet?

One of my favorite things about puzzles is how peaceful they are.

Sure, escape rooms can be cacophonous, and dropping a jigsaw puzzle can be infuriating, but for the most part, puzzles are soothing.

The satisfying scratch of pencil on paper as you fill in a word, watching the pile of unplaced jigsaw pieces slowly dwindle as the picture continues to form, getting a little victory chime when you solve a puzzle in your favorite app…

Board games, on the other hand, tend to get loud.

Sometimes, it’s good-natured debate or enthusiastic contributions, like when things get tense in a cooperative game, or when the game generally encourages rambunctiousness, like Throw Throw Burrito.

Other times, it’s a by-product of the gameplay itself. There’s a fair amount of frenzied clacking in Hungry Hungry Hippos, for instance, but I never hear people complain about the noise that comes along with a round or two of marble-chomping.

[Image courtesy of Grey Mass Games.]

Of course, that increase in volume can be for reasons that are a little more heated. Maybe someone betrayed someone else in a game like Sheriff of Nottingham. Monopoly famously inspires people to flip the board in frustration.

Social deduction games where identities are secret, or where there’s some level of deception involved, also tend to get pretty loud. Whether it’s Mafia, Ultimate Werewolf, Secret Hitler, Blood on the Clocktower, or others, raised voices are common.

But when it comes to loud board games, I think we can all agree that one particular dexterity takes the cake.

Say it with me now…

JENGA!

Yes, Jenga — by design — is loud. The only way the game can end is with a toppling tower of wooden blocks. CRASH! I know several board game cafes that have banned it for that specific reason.

Sure, KerPlunk can be loud, but even a stack of falling marbles doesn’t seem to compare to the jarring clatter of a stack of Jenga tiles hitting the table and/or the floor.

Sure, Perfection can be loud, but that’s kind of the point. You’re trying to complete the task BEFORE the buzzer. So it is possible to play without the cacophony.

Jenga is so infamously loud that there are other games that sell themselves on being quieter than Jenga but offering the same stacking mechanic. Rhino Hero and Rhino Hero Super Battle employ cards instead of wooden blocks, so the collapse is less more tolerable, while Catch the Moon employs ladders, which makes for an oddly soothing yet still stressful game experience.

But where do you stand on noise-making games and puzzles? Do you like them soothing and soft or calamitous and crashing? And just what is the loudest game? Let us know in the comments section below. We’d love to hear from you.


Thanks for visiting PuzzleNation Blog today! Be sure to sign up for our newsletter to stay up-to-date on everything PuzzleNation!

You can also share your pictures with us on Instagram, friend us on Facebook, check us out on TwitterPinterest, and Tumblr, and explore the always-expanding library of PuzzleNation apps and games on our website!

6 thoughts on “What’s Better in Puzzles and Games – Loud or Quiet?

  1. Hi!
    Arieth Ninja from NorWesCon!
    Your StarWars Escape room was awesome and I really hope you do a blog about it!
    >.> FYI, you cannot log into Twitter to respond on the comment session (I tried, trice, it expires after you hit authorize)

    I didn’t record the escape room part because I wasn’t sure if that was allowed, but I did record me doing the radiation puzzle and that will be posted on my YouTube channel later today, if you want a link, just message me back. it took me about 45 minutes to put it on power point, and another 20 to beat it I think

    I would like to point out, not everybody has access to printers. I think we might have two printers in our house, but one was broken two moves ago (i don’t know why we still have it) and since they don’t know which is which, the other hasn’t been hooked up.

    For puzzles like the radiation, recommend we use power point or google slides. Or maybe, create a simple app that has it for the background and we can move the pieces like i do on power point. In a years time, with enough notice, I might know how to make an app like that myself.

    But that was so much fun! I really like puzzle games, and had always wanted to do an escape room. If you ever need a play tester, feel free to give me a poke,

  2. Oh!
    Also, idea for the next online scavenger hunt you do, be it here, or a con…

    Consider hiding clues all over the website. Maybe make a small icon that can be easily over looked but if you click on it you’re given a clue or an Easter egg.

    • I definitely had ideas for something like this, but it fell by the wayside once we had the actors cast! Still, something to definitely consider for the future!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s