Long-time readers know that we periodically invite our fellow puzzlers and PuzzleNationers to show off their wordplay skills with puzzly prompts like our recurring hashtag game. We even invite our friends at Penny Dell Puzzles to participate!
A few months ago, we did things a little differently. A member of the Penny Dell crew cooked up an image for us, New Yorker-style, and we challenged our friends and readers to compose the perfect caption for it.
Well, in honor of Halloween, we held another Caption Contest, and this time, there were three images to choose from!
So, without further ado, let’s check out what all these clever folks conjured up!
#1
“Knew my old American Crossword Puzzle Tournament costumes would come in handy someday!”
“Well if if isn’t Sum-Bob Squarepants and Ed-Word Pencilhands!”
Penny Press version of “The Little Match Girl”: “Now don’t come home until every last PennyDell pencil is sold!”
“Seriously, I can’t believe you found an alternate solve on my outfit without even trying testsolving my puzzle grid outfit first!”
“So what do we have here? Edward Pencilhands and a Boy Named Sue-Doku?”
“You’ve heard of Edward Scissorhands? Well, this is his lesser known third cousin, Bobby Pencil-Fingers!”
“Sorry to tell you kid, but you’re not solvable, no matter how many pencils you use.”
“Nine rows, nine columns, nine boxes, nine pencils, nine TREATS?” Forget it, kid, try your warped Aristotelian logic on the McDermots next door!
So then I said, “If you still can’t guess what I am supposed to be, the solution is on page 130!”
#2
“Ah, so you’re the thief who’s been stealing toilet paper from the 3rd floor bathroom!”
Chasing down the mystery behind rising paper costs, puzzle publishers are squeezing the Charmin.
“I gotcha, Mr. or Mrs. Toilet Paper Bandit!” I’m so glad they didn’t use banana peels as their get away disguise.”
“Whodunnit solved! You need a pedicure!”
“Not so fast, toilet paper man! I heard that Dell Blockbuster Sudoku just hit the newsstands and there’s no way you’re beating me to it!”
“Next time, you may want to try gauze instead of Toilet Paper!”
“What does The Riddler dress up as on Halloween? A puzzle wrapped in an Enigma, of course!”
“You may be a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma, but I can still read you like an open book!”
“Hold still, I’m trying to decrypt you!”
“Let me follow you to your Cryptogram!”
“Just wait until your Mummy finds out the Pyramid Words you said!”
“Hold still, the clues are unfolding before me!”
#3
“After seeing the final ingredient for the soup, Gretel realized very quickly that making friends with the witch was only going to land her in hot water.”
“Eenie-meeni chili-beanie – I think this cauldron needs more pepper.”
“This isn’t like the Alphabet Soup on the Penny Press app at all!”
“The recipe for Alphabet Soup calls for a bay leaf, not eye of newt!”
“Matilda you fool! When I said “Eye of Newt”, I didn’t mean the 50th Speaker of the House!”
“Double, puzzle, toil and trouble;
Fire burn and cauldron bubble.
Puzzles appear in a slimy puddle–
Maybe the clue is ‘Barney Rubble’.”
“This isn’t how you find the Missing Vowels for the curse; I’ll look it up on the Penny Dell website on my iPhone!”
“I can’t ever remember what goes into this Alphabet Soup!”
“It keeps saying to start the Alphabet Soup with ‘Conjecture’ but I don’t understand where they are getting the E,C and T from!” the short witch exclaimed, as she read the directions aloud.
RECIPE TIME: WIZARD WORD STEW
In a large cauldron pour in ALPHABET SOUP, BITS AND PIECES of a SPIDER’S WEB, Lizard HEAD & TAILS, and a dash of HOCUS POCUS. Recite CODEWORDS until stew boils and BUBBLES and then serve with CRACKERS.
Have you come up with any fun captions for these images? Let us know! We’d love to see them!
Thanks for visiting PuzzleNation Blog today! Be sure to sign up for our newsletter to stay up-to-date on everything PuzzleNation!
You can also share your pictures with us on Instagram, friend us on Facebook, check us out on Twitter, Pinterest, and Tumblr, and explore the always-expanding library of PuzzleNation apps and games on our website!
PuzzleNation.com Blog 